Rothrock Realty Team logo ROTHROCK REALTY TEAM
Property management · Owner guides

Rent or sell your San Antonio-area home? The numbers, town by town

Whether to rent a home out or sell it depends on your mortgage, taxes and plans - but it starts with what it would rent for against what it would sell for. Here is that comparison for three-bedroom homes, from this week's MLS.

Reviewed October 2026.

Three-bedroom homes, this week

TownMedian rentMedian priceGross yieldRentals / for sale
Cibolo$1,840$226,0009.8%38 / 12
Kirby$1,360$183,0008.9%6 / 15
Von Ormy$1,620$228,0008.5%6 / 53
Windcrest$2,250$318,0008.5%5 / 18
Elmendorf$1,500$224,0008.0%9 / 60
Live Oak$1,595$239,0008.0%21 / 27
San Antonio$1,650$248,0008.0%1,775 / 3,014
Converse$1,595$245,0007.8%159 / 260
Boerne$2,500$395,0007.6%36 / 51
Schertz$1,795$289,0007.4%51 / 100
St Hedwig$1,650$270,0007.3%19 / 26
Universal City$1,400$250,0006.7%31 / 51
Helotes$2,275$408,0006.7%6 / 41
Alamo Heights$4,350$799,0006.5%6 / 5
Selma$1,495$285,0006.3%27 / 29
Marion$1,650$335,0005.9%5 / 61
Spring Branch$1,950$400,0005.9%14 / 101
La Vernia$2,200$467,0005.6%5 / 40
Canyon Lake$1,850$395,0005.6%40 / 216
Floresville$1,700$365,0005.6%5 / 74
Bandera$1,730$400,0005.2%5 / 90
Terrell Hills$2,100$534,0004.7%5 / 12
New Braunfels$1,695$450,0004.5%155 / 143

Gross yield is a year's rent divided by the price, before any costs. Asking rents and asking prices of three-bedroom homes listed in the MLS this week; towns with at least five of each.

Reading the numbers

A higher gross yield means rent covers more of the home's value each year. After property taxes - which in Bexar County and the towns around it are a large share - insurance, HOA dues, repairs and vacancy, the net return is a good deal lower than the gross.

The other half of the decision is your own: the rate on your mortgage, how much equity you have, whether you will want the home back, and whether you want to be a landlord at all.

Your home, not the median

Get an instant rent estimate for your address, and ask us to run the sale value next to it. We will tell you which way the numbers point.

Questions

Where in the San Antonio area do rental homes yield the most?

Among towns with enough three-bedroom homes listed this week, Cibolo shows the highest gross yield, at about 9.8%: a median rent of $1,840 against a median asking price of $226,000.

General information about Texas rules, not legal advice. For a specific situation, speak to a Texas attorney.